Springer Netherlands

Conditions of Collective Commitment in Sector-Specific Coordinated Governance Initiatives

van Schoor, B. & Luetge, C. Crime Law Soc Change (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10611-017-9714-2

Although both the problem of corruption and its detrimental effects on society, economy, and environment has widely been recognized, corruption remains one of the most challenging problems of today. In light of globalization, the exclusive focus on compliance-oriented measures such as sharpening laws seems to be more and more ineffective.

Apparently, the problem is not so much a lack of anti-corruption regulation, but rather a lack of enforcement of existing regulatory frameworks. This governance gap is increasingly tackled by the business sector. As a consequence, new governance mechanisms characterized by the involvement of non-state actors have emerged in recent years, in an attempt to fill this gap.

These Coordinated Governance Initiatives in which companies along with representatives of other societal sectors join forces to tackle the problem of corruption have not been in the focus of research so far. More research is needed particularly on the effectiveness of these collective anti-corruption efforts to explain whether this approach is useful to curb corruption. Therefore, we attempt to identify potential success factors of Coordinated Governance Initiatives that aim to curb corruption by means of a qualitative multiple-case study.

Twenty semi-structured interviews were conducted with members of three different initiatives. Additionally, secondary data sources were examined. Three different anti-corruption initiatives were selected: the Ethics Management of the Bavarian Construction Industry (EMB), the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI), and the Maritime Anti-Corruption Network (MACN).

We found five success factors and one basic prerequisite for sector-specific Coordinated Governance Initiatives. Although the identification of success factors of Coordinated Governance Initiatives is just the first step in the assessment of these initiatives, results indicate that a collective commitment obviously matters when it comes to fighting corruption.


01/2017 (6 years ago)


van Schoor, B. & Luetge, C. Crime Law Soc Change (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10611-017-9714-2


Related publications


Engaging the private sector in Collective Action against corruption

2022 | Basel Institute on Governance

Scarlet Wannenwetsch
corruption prevention

Siemens Integrity Initiative Annual Report 2021

2022 | Siemens AG

Case study, Report

Doing Business With Integrity: Stories from SMEs in Europe and Eurasia

2022 | CIPE Europe & Eurasia and CIPE Center for Accountable Investment


Is Collective Action against corruption a competition risk for companies? - from Perspectives on Antitrust Compliance

2022 | Concurrences in collaboration with the International Chamber of Commerce

Gemma Aiolfi, Cecilia Müller…


Integrity pacts in the EU: Suitability, set up, and implementation

2022 | Transparency International

Rafael García Aceves


Anticorruption Guidance for Partners of State-Owned Enterprises

2022 | Natural Resource Governance Institute

state-owned enterprisesanti-corruption complianceanti-bribery measuresnatural resource managementdue diligence


Papering over cracks or building stronger systems together? Financial crime in the context of covid-19

2021 | Basel Institute on Governance


Policy on Responsible Investing 2022 – CDC Group (British International Investment)

2021 | CDC Group (British International Investment)

Policy brief

Policy Brief 8: It takes a network to defeat a network – What Collective Action practitioners can learn from research into corrupt networks

2021 | Basel Institute on Governance

Claudia Baez Camargo, Jacopo Costa, Vanessa Hans, Lucy Koechlin, Scarlet Wannenwetsch
informal networksprivate-sector corruptionanti-corruption evidencemulti-stakeholder initiativesCollective Action Initiativeinformal governance


B20 Italy Integrity and Compliance Policy Paper 2021

2021 | B20 Italy

business integrity


Recommendation of the Council for OECD Further Combating Bribery of Foreign Public Officials in International Business Transactions (2021 Anti-Bribery Recommendation)

2021 | Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD)

United Nations Global Compact: Communication on Engagement 2021

2021 | Basel Institute on Governance

UN Global Compact


Input for the Roadmap for the next decade - Building blocks for realizing UNGPs implementation toward 2030

2021 | Institute of Employers (IOE), Business at OECD (BIAC), BusinessEurope


B20 Integrity and Compliance Task Force – Key Reflections and Suggestions from Members

2021 | The B Team; World Economic Forum Partnering Against Corruption Initiative



Key developments in mandatory human rights due diligence and supply chain law: Considerations for employers

2021 | International Organisation of Employers (IoE), Konrad Adenauer Stiftung (KAS)

anti-corruption compliance

Annual report

Annual Report 2020

2021 | Basel Institute on Governance


Beneficial ownership transparency – a GCFCC position paper

2021 | Global Coalition to Fight Financial Crime (GCFFC)


Siemens Integrity Initiative Annual Report 2020

2021 | Siemens AG


UNGASS 2021 Political Declaration

2021 | United Nations


Guidelines, Report

Uniting against Corruption: A Playbook on Anti-Corruption Collective Action

2021 | United Nations Global Compact