Basel Institute on Governance

Working Paper 32: Private-sector engagement in the fight against illegal wildlife trade

This working paper explores efforts by and with private-sector organisations to combat the multibillion-dollar illegal wildlife trade (IWT) and/or strengthen their resistance to IWT risks, with a focus on the East Africa – Southeast Asia trading chain.

Executive summary

There is widespread and growing awareness of the need for greater involvement of the private sector in efforts to prevent IWT. The transport and financial industries are the most clearly affected: the illegal products are usually trafficked via commercial land, sea and air transport services, and financial transactions take place via regulated financial services providers and the global banking system.

For their part, companies are starting to perceive of IWT not just as a conservation issue, and therefore confined to corporate social responsibility departments, but in terms of the risks this illegal trade presents to their business. These risks are tightly intertwined with other risks, particularly corruption and security.

Current multi-stakeholder initiatives aimed specifically at tackling industry-specific IWT risks show great promise to create a virtuous circle of engagement and action, but are still in their infant stages. Challenges include getting all relevant stakeholders around the table and building a strong business case for engagement that takes into account companies' specific risks and needs. At the moment, key industry sectors remain unrepresented and will therefore act as a weak link that wildlife traffickers can exploit.

Companies' levels of engagement in multi-stakeholder initiatives vary wildly and most are still unclear as to which departments and job functions are the most relevant in this sphere. Action is often ad-hoc and driven by individual "champions", and funding is neither adequate nor sustainable.

Lastly, there is clearly difficulty in moving from commitment to action, in other words for companies to not only sign commitments on paper but operationalise them. Clearer monitoring and evaluation mechanisms would help to increase accountability in this regard.

A basic but major identified need is for more reliable, targeted and actionable information and intelligence on IWT, to enable companies to take informed internal measures, co-develop industry guidelines and effect real systems change. This can best be achieved through mechanisms that allow all stakeholders to pool information and resources in pursuit of their common goals.

These challenges echo some of the challenges addressed over the years by Collective Action initiatives focused on tackling shared corruption challenges.

This similarity, as well as the strong links between corruption and IWT, means that practitioners can benefit from lessons learned from anti-corruption Collective Action initiatives and do not need to reinvent the wheel.

About this Working Paper

This paper is part of the Basel Institute on Governance Working Paper Series, ISSN: 2624-9650.

Published

12/2019 (4 years ago)

Authors

Scarlet Wannenwetsch
Gemma Aiolfi

Document

Related publications

Working paper

(Forthcoming) Working Paper 50: Seedlings of hope: Addressing corruption linked to crimes that impact the environment in line with UNCAC Resolution 8/12

2023 | Basel Institute on Governance

Sophie Lemaître

Working paper

(Forthcoming) Working Paper 49: Dirty deals – Case studies on corruption in waste management and trade

2023 | Basel Institute on Governance

Nancy Isarin, Claudia Baez Camargo, Amanda Cabrejo
waste managementillegal waste tradeBasel Convention

Guidelines

Translating political economy insights into conservation practice: a six-step guide

2023 | Targeting Natural Resource Corruption (TNRC) project

Micol Martini, Saba Kassa

Guidelines

Conflict of interest guidelines for Indonesian public institutions (Pedoman tentang Konflik Kepentingan)

2023 |

Niels Wohlwend, Lakso Anindito, Justin Snyder

Research case study

Research case study 4: Deconstructing a criminal network involved in illegal wildlife trade between East Africa and Southeast Asia

2023 | Basel Institute on Governance

Jacopo Costa
social network analysisnetwork ethnographyillegal wildlife tradeinformal governanceEast AfricaSoutheast Asia

Guidelines

Guide to strengthening internal controls to prevent corruption in illegal wildlife trade enforcement

2023 | Targeting Natural Resource Corruption (TNRC) project

Rebecca Batts
internal controls

Article

Guide to conducting corruption risk assessments in a wildlife law enforcement context

2023 | Targeting Natural Resource Corruption (TNRC) project

corruption risk assessment

Working paper

How corruption threatens the forests of Ukraine: Typology and case studies on corruption and illegal logging.

2023 | Basel Institute on Governance

Yehor Hrynyk, Andrii Biletskyi, Amanda Cabrejo

Article

Internal controls and illegal wildlife trade: A systemic approach to corruption prevention and law enforcement integrity

2023 | Targeting Natural Resource Corruption (TNRC) project

Rebecca Batts

Article

Law enforcement, criminal justice and natural resource corruption - a TNRC guide

2022 | Targeting Natural Resource Corruption (TNRC) project

law enforcementcriminal justice systemconservationnatural resource corruptionenvironmental corruption

How political economy analysis can support corruption risk assessments to strengthen law enforcement against wildlife crimes

2022 | Targeting Natural Resource Corruption (TNRC) project

Saba Kassa, Jacopo Costa, Cosimo Stahl, Claudia Baez Camargo

Report

Basel Gold Day II: Recycled Gold – From awareness to collective action on recycled gold and artisanal mining

2022 | Office Pieth; Precious Metals Impact Forum

gold laundering

Article

Illicit financial flows and natural resource corruption - a TNRC guide

2022 | Targeting Natural Resource Corruption (TNRC) project

illicit financial flowsconservationfollow the moneynatural resource corruptionenvironmental corruption

Policy brief

Policy Brief 10: Using anti-money laundering frameworks to fight illegal wildlife trade in Uganda

2022 | Basel Institute on Governance

Tom Walugembe
illegal wildlife tradeAnti-money launderinglaw enforcementfinancial investigationsEast Africawildlife crimeprosecution

Article, Commissioned study

Working Paper 39: Behavioural drivers of corruption facilitating illegal wildlife trade – Problem analysis and state of the field review

2022 | Basel Institute on Governance; TRAFFIC

Claudia Baez Camargo, Gayle Burgess
natural resource managementillegal wildlife tradesocial normsbehavioural insights

Article, Commissioned study

Where are the weakest links in the illegal wildlife trade enforcement chain? Lessons from corruption risk assessments with agencies in three countries

2022 | Targeting Natural Resource Corruption (TNRC) project

Manuel Medina, Juhani Grossmann, Taradhinta Sur…, Monica Guy
corruption risk assessmentillegal wildlife tradewildlife crimelaw enforcementcorruption risk management

Quick guide

Quick Guide 25: Tax investigations and illegal wildlife trade

2022 | Basel Institute on Governance

jovile.mungyereza
tax investigationstax evasionillegal wildlife tradewildlife trafficking

Quick guide

Quick Guide 24: Internal controls and anti-corruption

2022 | Basel Institute on Governance

Rebecca Batts
internal controlscorruption risk managementinternal audits

Article

Determinants and drivers of wildlife trafficking: A qualitative analysis in Uganda

2022 | Journal of International Wildlife Law & Policy

Saba Kassa, Claudia Baez Camargo, Jacopo Costa, Robert Lugolobi
wildlife traffickingillegal wildlife tradeenvironmental crimebehavioural driverssocial norms

Article, Commissioned study

Targeting Profit: Non-Conviction Based Forfeiture in Environmental Crime

2022 | Targeting Natural Resource Corruption (TNRC) project

Jonathan Spicer, Juhani Grossmann
non-conviction-based forfeitureasset recovery guidanceillicit enrichmentunexplained wealthenvironmental crimeenvironmental corruption